I've been pursuing my geeky, nerdy, and fannish interest in this year's Emmy Award nominations ever since I wrote about "Westworld," "Stranger Things" and "The Handmaid's Tale" making news with multiple Emmy nominations for drama series. I continued my pursuit with posts about Star Wars and The Walking Dead franchise. Today, it's time to write about the comic book adaptation shows.
"Gotham" earned three nominations, nearly as much as the rest of the comic book adaptation shows nominated combined. Three of those were Marvel shows and the last was for an animated show, which means that "Supergirl," the big winner among superhero shows at this year's Saturn Awards and the most nominated superhero show at this year's Teen Choice Awards, was shut out, as were all the rest of the DC shows. This confirms my opinion that "Gotham" is the superhero show the television professionals watch and like, while "Supergirl" is the show the fans most like.*
Follow over the jump for the nominations.
I'll be a good environmentalist and recycle what I wrote about two of the nominations.
So far, "Gotham" is not in competition with any of Marvel's television shows. That changes with the next category.Sound Editing for a SeriesLook, one of three nominations for "Gotham!" Cool, but I expect either "Westworld" or "Stranger Things" will win.
Benjamin Cook, Stefan Henrix, Mike Szakmeister, Shaugnessy Hare, Tim Tuchrello, Brett Voss, Michael Baber, Jeffrey Wilhoit & Dylan Tuomy-Wilhoit (“Black Sails”)
George Haddad, Chad J. Hughes, Dale Chaloukian, David Barbee, Julie Altus, Ashley Revell, Joey Sabella & Joanie Rowe (“Gotham”)
Craig A. Dellinger, Ryne Gierke, Eric Raber, Shawn Kennelly, Jeff Charbonneau, Melissa Kennelly & Vince Nicastro (“Homeland”)
Bradley North, Craig Henighan, Jordan Wilby, Jonathan Golodner, Tiffany S. Griffth, Sam Munoz, Sam Munoz, David Klotz, Noel Vought & Ginger Geary (“Stranger Things”)
Thomas E. deGorter, Matthew Sawelson, Brian Armstrong, Fred Paragano, Mark Allen, Marc Glassman, Sebastian Visconti, Geordy Sincavage, Michael Head, Christopher Kaller, Rick Owens & Tara Blume Norton (“Westworld”)Special Visual Effects in a Supporting RoleI'm rooting for "Gotham," but wouldn't be surprised if "The Handmaid's Tale" pulled this off.
Ben Turner, Tom Debenham, Standish Millennas, Kim Phelan, Oliver Cubbage, Lionel Heath, Charlie Bennet, Stephen Smith, Carmine Agnone (“The Crown” — “Windsor”)
Eric Durst, Lenka Líkarová, Viktor Muller, Marek Ruth, Tomáš Kalhous, Lukáš Herrmann, Pavel Kolár, Petr Hastík, Vit Komrzý (“Genius” — “Einstein: Chapter One”)
Thomas Mahoney, Matthew Wheelon Hunt, Alex Gitler, Sina San, Michael Capton, Jon Anastasiades, Ryan Bauer, Mark Anthony Nazal, Randy Little (“Gotham” — “Heavydirtysoul”)
Brendan Taylor, Stephen Lebed, Leo Bovell, Martin O’Brien, Winston Lee, Kelly Knauff, Zach Dembinski, Mike Suta, Cameron Kerr (“The Handmaid’s Tale” — “Birth Day”)
Henry Badgett, Tracy McCreary, Angela Barson, Lucy Ainsworth-Taylor, Nic Birmingham, Simon Rowe, Alexander Kirichenko, Finlay Duncan, Colin Gorry (“Taboo” — “Episode 1”)
Stunt Coordination For a Drama Series, Limited Series Or MovieWow, what an action-packed field! The only show missing is "The Walking Dead," which was nominated in this category two years ago. Here, "Gotham" is in direct competition with "Marvel's Luke Cage" in the latter's only nominated category. I'm rooting for "Gotham," but I'm not optimistic. All the rest of the action shows have great stunts and "The Blacklist" won this category three years ago ("Game of Thrones," which one this category last year, is not eligible).
Cort L. Hessler III (“The Blacklist”)
Christopher Place (“Blindspot”)
Norman Douglass (“Gotham”)
Jeff Wolfe (“MacGyver”)
James Lew (“Marvel’s Luke Cage”)
The next two nominations also pit Marvel vs. DC productions against each other.
Short Form Animated ProgramIn a contest between "Marvel’s Rocket & Groot" and "Teen Titans Go!", I'd vote for the Teen Titans. Unfortunately, I doubt either will win. Instead, I think the favorite is "Adventure Time," which has been nominated multiple times and won six statures over the years.
“Adventure Time” (Cartoon Network)
“Disney Mickey Mouse” (Disney Channel)
“Marvel’s Rocket & Groot” (Disney XD App)
“Steven Universe” (Cartoon Network)
“Teen Titans Go!” (Cartoon Network)
The final category includes the last nomination for a comic-book adaptation show. I'll recycle and elaborate on what I wrote about the category in "Fear the Walking Dead: Passage" contributes to diversity at the 2017 Primetime Emmy Awards.
"Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.: Slingshot" should just be happy to be nominated.Short Form Comedy or Drama SeriesI'd love for ["Fear the Walking Dead: Passage"] to win, but I suspect the Emmy voters would prefer “Los Pollos Hermanos Employee Training,” a companion to "Better Call Saul," which they also like.
“Brown Girls” (Open TV)
“Fear The Walking Dead: Passage” (AMC.com)
“Hack Into Broad City” (ComedyCentral.com)
“Los Pollos Hermanos Employee Training” (AMC)
“Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.: Slingshot” (ABCd/ABC.com)
That's it for the superhero shows at this year's Primetime Creative Arts Emmy Awards. I'll return to the Emmys later this week, after I write about the winners of the Television Critics Association Awards tomorrow. Stay tuned.
*It reminds me of the situation with "Game of Thrones' vs. 'Outlander"; as I've observed, "'Outlander' is more popular with the fans who care to vote than 'Game of Thrones,'" while the latter is more popular with the Hollywood professionals, earning 39 Emmys total so far. That's a rivalry that will have to wait until next year's Emmy Awards, as neither show had qualifying episodes during the season just concluded.